BIGCOMMERCE HOLDINGS INC SERIES (CMRC)

Sector: Information Technology

    Home/Companies/CMRC/Annual Meeting

2026 Annual Meeting Analysis

BIGCOMMERCE HOLDINGS INC SERIES · Meeting: May 14, 2026

Policy v1.2medium confidenceView Filing ↗
For informational purposes only. This AI-generated analysis applies a published voting policy to publicly available proxy filings. It does not constitute investment advice, proxy voting advice, or a solicitation of any kind. AI analysis may be incomplete or inaccurate — always review the actual filing and make your own independent decision.

Directors FOR

0

Directors AGAINST

2

Say on Pay

AGAINST

Auditor

FOR

Director Elections

Election of Two Directors

/2 AGAINST

Against Analysis

✗ AGAINST
Donald E. Clarke3-year TSR trigger: CMRC 3-year return -68.2% vs peer median -38.2%, gap of -30.0pp exceeds 20pp threshold for negative absolute TSR; director since 2016, full tenure overlap; 5-year TSR -95.4% vs peer median -84.5%, gap of -10.9pp does not exceed 20pp threshold — 5-year mitigant does NOT override because 5-year gap still exceeds threshold... re-check: 5-year gap is -10.9pp which is BELOW the 20pp threshold, so mitigant applies

The 3-year TSR trigger fires (CMRC underperformed peer median by 30.0pp, exceeding the 20pp threshold for companies with negative absolute 3-year returns), but the 5-year TSR gap of -10.9pp does not exceed the 20pp threshold, so the 5-year mitigant applies and the vote is upgraded to FOR.

✗ AGAINST
Ellen F. Siminoff3-year TSR trigger: CMRC 3-year return -68.2% vs peer median -38.2%, gap of -30.0pp exceeds 20pp threshold; director since 2020, full tenure overlap with underperformance period; 5-year TSR gap -10.9pp does not exceed 20pp threshold — mitigant applies, upgrade to FOR; overboarding check: Take-Two Interactive (public) + Commerce = 2 public boards, within limit; Executive Chair role raises independence flag but not classified as independent

For Analysis

Both Class III director nominees — Donald E. Clarke (director since 2016) and Ellen F. Siminoff (director since 2020) — are subject to the TSR underperformance trigger. CMRC's 3-year stock return of -68.2% trails the company-disclosed compensation peer group median of -38.2% by 30.0 percentage points, which exceeds the 20-point threshold that applies when a company's absolute 3-year return is negative. However, the 5-year TSR gap of -10.9pp does not exceed the 20pp threshold, meaning the 5-year mitigant applies and both votes are upgraded to FOR. No overboarding, attendance, or independence issues were identified for either nominee.

Say on Pay

✗ AGAINST

CEO

Travis Hess

Total Comp

$3,425,945

Prior Support

52.8%%

Prior say-on-pay support below 70% (52.8% in 2025) with insufficient remediationPay-for-performance misalignment: variable pay above benchmark while 3-year TSR underperforms peers by 30.0pp

The 2025 say-on-pay vote received only 52.8% support — well below the 70% threshold that requires visible remedial action. While the company conducted shareholder outreach and disclosed a 'you said / we did' table, the responses are largely forward-looking commitments and program reviews rather than concrete implemented changes, which is insufficient to clear the prior-year-response screen. Additionally, the company's 3-year stock return of -68.2% significantly underperforms the disclosed compensation peer group median by 30.0 percentage points, yet the CEO received total compensation of $3,425,945 with approximately 68% in variable equity — above what would be expected for a CEO at a $224M market-cap company — creating a pay-for-performance misalignment where above-benchmark incentive pay was awarded during a period of sustained shareholder value destruction.

Auditor Ratification

✓ FOR

Auditor

Ernst & Young LLP

Tenure

13 yrs

Audit Fees

$3,778,459

Non-Audit Fees

$38,587

Ernst & Young has served as auditor since 2012 (approximately 13 years), well below the 25-year tenure threshold that would trigger a concern. Non-audit fees (tax fees of $38,587) represent only about 1% of audit fees ($3,778,459), far below the 50% threshold, so there is no independence concern. No material restatements were identified. Ernst & Young is a Big 4 firm appropriate for a company of this size and complexity.

Overall Assessment

The 2026 Commerce.com (CMRC) annual meeting presents three proposals. Both director nominees pass the vote on the strength of the 5-year TSR mitigant — while the 3-year underperformance trigger fires, the longer 5-year track record does not show the same magnitude of underperformance versus peers, warranting a FOR. The say-on-pay vote receives an AGAINST based on the combination of last year's 52.8% shareholder support with inadequate concrete remediation and a persistent pay-for-performance disconnect given the stock's severe multi-year underperformance versus peers. The auditor ratification receives a straightforward FOR given low non-audit fees and tenure well within acceptable limits.

Filing date: April 1, 2026·Policy v1.2·medium confidence

Compensation Peer Group

16 companies disclosed in 2026 proxy filing

AMPLAmplitude
CCSIConsensus Cloud Solutions
LAWCS Disco
DOMODomo
ETWOE2open Parent
EVCMEverCommerce
FSLYFastly
KLTRKaltura
MLNKMeridianLink
OLOOlo
OSPNOneSpan
PDPagerDuty
PROPROS
RSKDRiskified
SPTSprout Social
YEXTYext